Posts tagged cost

Olympic profligacy

In case you hadn’t guessed, yet, i’m not a fan of the Olympics. And while a part of that merely reflects a very personal aversion to team sporty things, there is, too, something I find more than a little tawdry, small-minded, about the entire enterprise.

Already, we have had headline-seeking politicians and journalists, on little evidence beyond a hoped-for lift to their own careers, putting weight behind a campaign likely to make the lives of many sex workers just that bit more violent and dangerous over the next couple of months. And now, as the torch – sorry, torches – set off around Britain, comes evidence both of profligacy and…possibly… just a little free-booting along the way. Read the rest of this entry »

Comments (3) »

“special” services…for special people

Two outwardly unrelated stories about the NHS, cropping up in the last couple of days, maybe provide some insight into the way in which public, press and, yes, trans community, too, deal with issues in the media spotlight.

Let’s start with some special privilege awarded to a group whose gender creds (and orientation) might just be considered by some members of the public to be ever so slightly dubious. I mean, of course, dancers. Read the rest of this entry »

Comments (5) »

Mythogenesis: more on trans costs

OK. Still a need for a detailed costs paper – just to show the reptiles that there is an alternative version. Meanwhile, however, here’s the intriguing story of how we ended up with the myth of a £60k cost for MtF grs. Many thanks to Andrea for the ferret…

As far as her research goes, the first mention of £60,000 in connection with grs turned up in January 2009. Before then, apart from the fact that papers picked up on detail and sometimes got the number of potential ops wrong, they were mostly quoting £10k, which was about right.

This was in a policy document produced by the East Midlands Clinical Priorities Advisory Group, which came out with £60k as an upper limit for more complex FtM re-assignment surgery (but a range of £20k to £60k quoted) and £12k for MtF.

Fast forward to March of that year, when the Sun referenced that figure in respect of a story about “a Turkish transsexual woman” (sic) granted UK asylum. The focus, doncha know, is how awful it is that these bleedin forinners come over here and take our resource. And the upper limit of £60k has magically transformed into “at least £60,000-worth of NHS surgery”.

Interestingly, the writer of this piece uses the phrase “£60,000 spent already”, which is to cover ”the first phase of the complex surgery”.

Roll on April 2010 when a transsexual had the gall to threaten legal action over a boob job. Miranda Lee, 40, claimed she had been left “half man, half woman” and wanted her health authority to pay for her to become a “real woman”.

The journo behind this piece in the Sun added: “Her transformation has already cost taxpayers £60,000 and the breast op could add another £8,000”. Huh? Recycled copy? Perhaps.

The local press then followed the Sun, stating: “It is thought operations like Miranda’s can cost up to £60,000.”

Like. Huh? It is thought? As though this is a prediction for climate change, when a single simple phone call could actually establish exactly how much the amount actually is.

At about the same time, E Midlands NHS trust were still quoting £12,000 for MtoF and £20,000-£60,000 for FtoM. However, by the time Miranda’s case came to court all the papers were quoting the figure as money she had spent: the Telegraph, f’rinstance, happily gave £60,000

One minor light in the dark: an interview given by a certain woman of trans history to the Stamford Mercury led to the correct figure being quoted.

In September of this year, the Sun turned back to considering FtM transition, with the story of Lee and a procedure which “involves several major operations and costs in excess of £60,000”.

And that brings us pretty much up to date with the case of Cathy Daniels. I’ve covered that one off and I will be interested in following this a bit further tomorrow. Basically, the trail starts with the Lancashire Telegraph which quotes the £60,000 figure as gospel, runs on into the Star with the same figure intact, and then pops up in the Sun with some rather spiteful digs about taxpayer funding added on top.

jane
xx

P.S. I’ll be phoning the Sun newsdesk tonight to inquire about where they got their figures from…and the Lancashire Telegraph tomorrow. WIll let you know how it turns out.

Comments (4) »

Budgeting for gender re-assignment

Hmmm. Since i’ve been getting a few questions about this in comments and in private e-mails, let’s get this set out once and for all.

If you go private, the following are the sort of costs you are likely to hit along the way, assuming you can’t get your pct to fund ANY of it. I’ll blog separately about that, since once you know what you’re about, you may be able to get them to pay for specific items.

Start with a specialist

First off is a visit to a specialist (I used Richard Curtis, but there are others at similar price levels). He diagnosed gender dysphoria (which had already been disgnosed by my local NHS psych service, so that helped) and said i needed one of two things before i started hormone therapy: three months real-life experience, or equivalent therapy.

I went belt and braces and did both, though in hindsight would not recommend the therapy. More on that later.

The specialist costs are approx. £240 per hour and i’d estimate i had one hour session and three to four half hour sesions…so we’re talking around £700.

Dubious benefits of therapy

Therapy was, i think, six sessions at around £40 per hour. Why would i not recommend it? At the time, i was still viewing the whole process through NHS goggles, and that view is that this is a mental health/psych led process. What i know now is that if you know, you know and personal therapy – at least around gender issues – turned out to be thoroughly irrelevant for me. Not just my experience, but that of several other trans women i know now, as well.

There is an argument for some therapy a) for nearest and dearest, for whom the process can be quite traumatic and b) around other issues. There is/was, for me, a degree of grief at not having been born female which i deal with, slowly.

Keep taking the tablets

Once past the initial assessment, you are into hormone territory. I tried patchesw first and then went on to pills. The patches didn’t work too well and i paid for my first battch of patches (£45 for three months supply): that was impetuous as i could have had them on the NHS.

Your pills or whatever are likely to cost you about £10-£15 per month – but if your GP is prepared to put them on prescription then you may make considerable saving there. Depends on GP and even part of the country: i am told that Camden pct still refuses to allow their GP’s to prescribe hormones, even where these have been initially prescribed by Charing Cross. That is a bit of NHS stupidity and hopefully will be resolved in time.

In addition to feminising hormones, you may add on something like Finasteride (if you have a receding hairline) and, when the testosterone starts to fight back, you will probably need an anti-testosterone jab or implant. That can be much pricier: my own (triptorelin) cost about £150 for a three-month jab – though again, it went through on prescription (each time with a practice sticker warning it was an expensive item).

Under the knife

You are eligible for grs 12 months after you commence hormones and assuming you have lived full-time rle. I’ve hardened. There have been scary moments along the way – some very scary indeed – but if you are serious about what you want, you will go rle and stay there.

I think there are good medical reasons for going sooner rather than later, and i’ll go into those later, too.

The op at Brighton was a flat £10,500, including some follow-up and dealing with the main complications. I understand from others that if you go to places like Thailand, you MAY spend less, even allowing for planes and hotels, but i am not an expert on that. In the end, what swung the choice for me was the thought of having to deal with complications. I don’t think i could handle going back to Thailand whilst, say, suffering major pain.

Preparing for surgery

Other things you NEED to invest in: you absolutely need your genital area electrolysed – and (my bad, this) it will take time. If you are uncircumcised, you will prob’ly get what is called a penile inversion and this requires far less electrolysis than the full penile-scrotal inversion that those who have been circumcised need. Allow anywhere between four and a dozen sessions…bear in mind most won’t treat you without a four-week gap between treatments and you see the issue. If you’re hairy, electrolysis can hold you up.

At £80-£90 per hour of electrolysis, this bit of your treatment can cost anywhere between £200 and £800…

You will also absolutely need to invest in a final opinion before you go under the knife. As i understand it, this only needs to be a “second professional opinion” and, if honest, is there to protect the back of the surgeon. I dopn’t know how wide you could draw this opinion (GP, perhaps…next door neighbour who happens to be a barrister?) but if you go the usual route and spend on a psych opinon of some sort, expect this to set you back £200-£400.

Total cost

In summary, getting from start to finish inside a year to 18 months is likely to cost you (privately):

Specialist £700
Hormones £200
Anti-testosterone £300-£450
Electrolysis £200-£800
GRS £10, 500
Final opinion £200-£400

That comes in at around £12k – and slightly less if you can get your pct to pick up some components – and maybe £14k tops if things don’t go to plan. I’ve not included therapy which could be anything from zilch to a couple of thousand!

Other stuff you may wish to invest in are personal electrolysis – for own body hair – and speech therapy. And if you are serious about looking good, you’ll possibly find your hair and make-up bills a bit larger than you are used to. :)

Keep the questions flying.

jane
xx

Comments (1) »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 101 other followers